The power of the zero

My great concern is not whether you have failed, but whether you are content with your failure.-Abraham Lincoln

As human beings, we will fail before we succeed, and sometimes we fail many, many times before we find success. If this is human nature, then I wonder…why isn’t this behavior encouraged, or sometimes even allowed inside our schools? Why do we cut off student learning in order to teach them some lesson of responsibility? Wouldn’t a better decision be to demand that they learn? We must insist that our schools become places of learning rather than houses of compliance.

The “zero” unfortunately carries a lot of power in education. Some teachers not only use it, but at times seem to enjoy doling zeroes out as the ultimate punishment. Should we allow the concept of zero to have this much power in our classrooms and schools? My answer is no. There is no room for ‘zero learning’ in a school. This is an oxymoron at best and a disservice to students at its worst.

There is no allowance for discontent with failure if we use zeroes. Students are permitted to move on to new concepts with little or no proficiency. Or worse yet…a student gets a zero but is actually quite proficient with a standard and the instructor never took the time to find out. Or the worst of all…a student is proficient, the instructor knows it, but the student did not turn in an assignment, so the zero is given.

Students need the time and space to fail, persevere, possibly fail again, and eventually find success. With curriculum guides and inventories, high stakes testing, and the factory model instructional methods we are given as teachers, no wonder some of the behaviors I previously mentioned have developed over the years. I am challenging us as an educational community to stop the madness. ‘Covering’ material and allowing students to move on without truly learning simply must cease.

I challenge you to quit using the zero. Don’t allow it any power in your learning environment. All a zero indicates is a lack of evidence, so treat it as such. Seek evidence of proficiency and when it there is room for improvement, work together with students to achieve mastery. We determine what we allow to be powerful and have control in our classrooms and schools. Let’s teach our kids to never be content with failure, but to treat it as an opportunity for growth and improvement. Learning is the most powerful force in education.

About the Author:


  1. Sra. Spanglish March 18, 2014 at 10:55 PM - Reply

    I get what you’re saying, and The Zero and I have gone many, many rounds in the last 10 years. But when you say, “the instructor never took the time to find out,” I feel, I guess, ACCUSED. Sometimes I think it is unreasonable to expect the instructor to “take the time to find out” when there are so many students in one class alone. If the instructor provides the opportunity to demonstrate proficiency, checks in with the student about said demonstration, but still GETS no demonstration, what’s an overworked educator to do?

    I was pretty sure one student last semester “got it” almost all of the time, but if he couldn’t be bothered to turn ANYTHING in after weekly–if not daily–reminders, parent calls, lectures on potential, and second chances, what can I possibly give him BUT a zero?

    People at my school think I’m too soft, “too kind” with my students already. I feel the whole Marzano, non-zero thing puts an unfair burden on teachers in many situations.

    I don’t want to be “too kind” AND “too cruel”!

  2. Mary Sullivan March 13, 2014 at 9:07 PM - Reply

    A zero tells us nothing about the student’s learning and all we need to know about a teacher’s mindset.

  3. Mme Bird March 13, 2014 at 9:43 AM - Reply

    Wow! Very powerful and I love the quote from Lincoln as a starter.

  4. Dereck Rhoads March 13, 2014 at 6:50 AM - Reply

    Grading is a huge topic and area for tons of growth. When teachers understand Standard-based Grading and use trend scoring they are better able to provide timely academic feedback for improved understanding.

  5. Ken O'Connor March 12, 2014 at 7:15 PM - Reply

    Well said Garnet. This is great. Will use it to try to get to some “rocks” that I know.

Leave A Comment