Survey says…

I asked my 9th grade students for narrative feedback on their first semester experiences in my classroom through a survey about our standards based learning environment.  We always have room to improve and grow, but we also have so much to be proud of.  My kids create the learning environment with me, and the responsibility for maintaining it is shared as well.

Several major themes seemed to develop from their responses – they enjoy the freedom to work at their own pace and choose their work, they do not feel stressed out regarding learning in my classroom, they feel safe to try new things and revisit their learning when proficiency levels are below the learning target, and they preferred a standards based grading system to emphasize learning over points, scores, and grades.  Here are a few examples of their responses:

On Freedom:
“I have the freedom to learn how I choose.”
“I like being able to have the freedom to do the things you need during class, without scripted backwork.”

On Stress Levels:
“I enjoy how unstressful the learning environment is.”
“I do not feel pressured to know everything right away – there is time to become proficient.”

On Safety of Learning:
“The learning environment is welcoming and makes you feel safe.”
“We can redo our assessments, so we can get better and better at it.”

On Standards Based Grading:
“I enjoy the learning atmosphere because of the grading system.”
“I like that we don’t have traditional grades, because it makes more sense.”

There is one more comment that I would like to highlight. It humbled me as it also reminded me what a huge impact we as educators have on kids.

“What I enjoy most about Spanish class is how I learn not only the language, but how to be something in the world.”

About the Author:


  1. Steve Mefford January 13, 2014 at 1:14 PM - Reply

    Incredible evidence of student engagement in a class. Amazing to see they are getting much more than just the traditional curriculum, but rather, a new way to look at learning and succeeding in life.

  2. Ms. Marchetti January 13, 2014 at 8:17 AM - Reply

    There are so many reasons why an SBL environment makes sense, but your last line clinches it: it makes students feel like they can “be something in the world” because SBL teaches the learner in addition to the learning.

    Are you teaching in an environment where you are expected to upload grades consistently–traditional letter grades? If so, how do you meet your administrators’ expectations while remaining faithful to the promise of SBG?

  3. Ms. Marchetti January 12, 2014 at 7:36 PM - Reply

    This comment has been removed by the author.

    • Garnet Hillman January 13, 2014 at 7:01 PM - Reply

      I also implement Standards Based Grading in a traditional setting. I report letter grades at the end of the semester. I use a 4 point scale for all summative assessments. I do not score formative work, just feedback for growth.

  4. Joy Kirr January 12, 2014 at 6:36 PM - Reply

    Garnet, I love that they recognize that it’s not as stressful. My 7th graders are taking advantage of that (a bit), but I think it’s important. It lets us focus more on the learning, of course! 🙂 (I don’t do “REAL” SBG – yet… but it’s coming down the pike – I hope!) Thanks for sharing student views – we often don’t!

Leave A Comment